LONDON -- North Macedonia and Albania face a risk of surging nationalism and unravelling economic reforms after EU closed the door for years on their hopes of joining EU
The promises have been broken, and what Zaev and Rama are afraid of becomes realistic
LONDON -- North Macedonia and Albania face a risk of surging nationalism and unravelling economic reforms after EU closed the door for years on their hopes of joining EU
Source: Tanjug
Close the entire text of the article here
Pool/Pool/Getty images/Ilustracija
Zoran Zaev, prime minister of North Macedonia, said in an interview that he feared a return to his ethnically divided country’s “bad past”, including a narrowly averted civil war in 2001. Edi Rama, prime minister of Albania, said in a separate interview that his country risked becoming “collateral damage” from the EU’s divisions over enlargement, "Financial Times" reports.
"The warnings from both Balkan leaders underline analysts’ fears that the EU’s failure to proceed with both countries’ accession process will destabilize a geopolitically delicate region where the influence of other countries including Russia and China is growing", FT reports.
It is reiterated that French President Emmanuel Macron had blocked opening accession talks with North Macedonia and Albania, with the Netherlands and Denmark also opposing negotiations with Tirana. Both Balkan countries have complained that the EU is not meeting its side of agreement.
Zaev said that he was worried that a sensitive agreement he negotiated with Greece last year to rename his country could be reopened due to growing nationalist sentiment.
“If there is enough nationalist rhetoric, radical acting and speeches in North Macedonia, that will give arguments to Greek politicians to use the same kind of rhetoric, and in return, that can lead everyone to take concrete steps which will not be good for my region or my country”, Zaev warned, pointing out the multiethnic nature of its country mainly populated by Macedonians and ethnic Albanians.
Zaev has already said he will resign as a sing of disapproving with EU policy, adding that the agreement with Athens could be in jeopardy if his party does not win on the next elections.
In Tirana, Mr Rama said that the decision not to open accession negotiations left a “heavy psychological shock in the country” and harmed the EU’s credibility in the region.
“We were cut twice from Europe brutally, once for five centuries under the Ottoman Empire and then for half a century under the most brutal communist regime. No one can live with the idea that there can be a third time", Rama said.
Both leaders said they understood the concerns of the EU member states that blocked the negotiations because they want to see reform in the bloc and of its enlargement policies, but they both agreed that any eventual membership was at least a decade off, and that their countries and the EU itself could meanwhile continue their reforms, FT reports.
Mr Rama said the need for internal EU reform was “not really a standing alibi for what is the core issue”. “Europe is in a period where it will get worse before it will get better and we are just the collateral damage of that”, Rama said.
Judy Dempsey, a non-resident senior fellow at Carnegie Europe, said that the EU’s credibility had been damaged because leaders had been told since 2003 that if they met the EU’s criteria, they would be admitted. Now, although Skopje at least had done so, it was being rejected on the grounds that the EU must be reformed first.
“Promises have been broken,” she said. “The Western Balkans is now easy picking for the Chinese and Russian influence”, Dempsey concluded. Zaev said he was worried about attempts to fill the vacuum due to accession process delay.
“This decision gives space for third forces, which are not very helpful, who do not offer us democracy, freedoms, and rule of law”, Zaev concluded.
(Mikael, 6 November 2019 02:46)
I know exactly what Macedonia is and I know more about it’s history that you ever will. The current people are not Macedonians since they are Slavic and your language is Bulgarian, but pretending to be Macedonian of ancient times. Why is it I understand your language but not Greek? Alexander the Great was Greek but lived in that region which is called Macedonia and you people are not Macedonians the Greeks are.
It was Tito that pandered to minorities like yours into thinking your Macedonian.
It’s financially unsustainable just like all the others Croatia, BiH, Montenegro etc. Serbia is the only one that can stand on its feet and prosper as we can see today.
Zaev and Rama have been promising the world and once in the EU the bank vaults in heaven would open up and Utopia. Its their hold on power that has them shaking mate not getting N/Macedonia or Albania into the EU.
(sj, 7 November 2019 10:16)
What is there to educate on self about Macedonia? The Albanians have more support and respect around the world than the so called mythical state called Macedonia. The Albanians living within Macedonia are step by step gaining what they need thanks to the concessions made by so called Macedonians to appease the EU and NATO. Recognising Kosovo also meant border changes within Macedonia. Well done so called Macedonias, make your country great again like Tito times. Macedonia Macedonia, Macedonia!!!!!!!!!!
(Al, 7 November 2019 00:16)
sj,
You seem to know nothing about Macedonia, yet you talk as if you are an expert. Please educate yourself about Macedonia before you make a complete fool of yourself.
(Mikael, 6 November 2019 02:46)
@ Mikael - I'm not sure sj is far off. Macedonia signed on WAY to many dotted lines...giving up her sovereignty, Integrity & Character...all on promises that we see today hold no water.
Now what? Go back on the deal with the Albanians, which grabbed Macedonia by the boo-boo and now is laughing? Go back on the deal with Greece, who now is laughing? Go back on de-recognizing "kosovaaaa" for the Srbs, who now are laughing?
Zaev was chosen to sacrifice Macedonia on the alter...The "True" Macedonians know this! The "Macedonians" who appeased the alligator hoping to be eaten last....well, SHAME on you!
(Watcherovic, 6 November 2019 23:15)
I never understood our idiot politicians and also our population also thinking that joining EU today will somehow as a miracle solve all our problems. Indeed its better to be equal in class called Balkan rather than a second hand citizien in a class called Europe.
We wasted 30 years of democracy with corruption, criminality, mass emigration etc to just open our eyes now and see we are again on the starting point. I wished someone comes in power with the idea to make things better for the albanian people, albanian cause, albanian problems first and only after see if its a need to join EU or whatever other organization. This is not easy because for decades now even the new generation has this idiot idea that getting rich faster by doing criminal things is better than beeing someone worthy for you society and your country. How can you blame them, for years the only thing they see on TV is peeps who start as poor politicians and end as top rank bilionaries in the region in just a decade
(Ordinary Albanian, 6 November 2019 20:11)
I have nothing against North Macedonia. However I am very surprised at some of the decisions they have taken over the past 20/25 years.
Firstly I could not understand why they wanted to break away from Serbia. Looking at how it is, they don't really have any friends around them, apart from Serbia. To the east they have Bulgaria who have for a long time had their eyes on a chunk (or all) of Macedonia. To the south there is Greece. I need not say any more about Greek/Macedonian relations over the years. And then they have Albania....ye, those land thieves who are determined to rip a chunk of Macedonia for their greater Albania dream.
Macedonia is occupied by nato and are told what to do (sovereign nation my ass). And now we see how the EU is taking the pi*s out of them.
Can anyone tell me why the N Macedonians wanted to go their separate way...??? To me its a real mystery with no benefits.
(View from the uk, 6 November 2019 19:28)
sj,
You seem to know nothing about Macedonia, yet you talk as if you are an expert. Please educate yourself about Macedonia before you make a complete fool of yourself.
(Mikael, 6 November 2019 02:46)
I certainly do not understand this statement.
Did they REALLY think that the EU, during forseeable future, would let these countries into the union??? With a huge amout of organized crime, poor people, nepotism, bribery, pollution and a risk for asylum seekers.
No not a chance in universe. A year ago, I talked with three french diplomats about this topic. One of them said 30 years and the other two said 30-40 years if everything goes smooth for the mentioned countries.
(Staff, 5 November 2019 18:44)
Joining the EU will do nothing for these countries except be given scraps and lots of new blue flags with yellow stars to put all over their government buildings, their population massively decrease and their politicians get even more richer (Njegos down under, 5 November 2019 13:01)
Politicians get richer. And that's also why some Serbs left Serbia in favor of "down under" (Australia).
(Make Serbia Great, 5 November 2019 17:57)
Joining the EU will do nothing for these countries except be given scraps and lots of new blue flags with yellow stars to put all over their government buildings, their population massively decrease and their politicians get even more richer
(Njegos down under, 5 November 2019 13:01)
In general: Nationalism will not decrease by EU talks or membership, on the contrary it increases.
As for China and Russia, these so called fellows/academics that actually do not understand this region well at all need to get a better scapegoat. China and Russia are in the Balkans in the same capacity they have been there 5, 10, 15 years ago.
(Realist, 5 November 2019 12:38)
Since Yugoslavia dissolved, there was always going to be a big question mark over the existence of the banana republic called Macedonia. Yugoslavia guaranteed the current Macedonia sovereignty and its constitution. Macedonia is hoping that the EU will take over from Yugoslavia, in fact opposite has happened. Bit by bit, every concession they made is creating their own demise. Like the UK will dissolve by 2025, Macedonia will cease to exist.
(Sl, 5 November 2019 12:11)
Miraculously joining the EU will somehow eliminate tension between different ethnic groups and no longer fuel nationalism??? What do they think is happening in Catalan region of Spain? Picking mushrooms?
No, its all about Zoran Zaev and Edi Rama making big promises to their respective people that joining the EU would bring wealth to their country. That is what its all about and now that the EU is short of cash and will not take on new members, all their promises of a better life are coming apart at the seams and their hold on power is looking tenuous.
(sj, 5 November 2019 10:25)
Miraculously joining the EU will somehow eliminate tension between different ethnic groups and no longer fuel nationalism??? What do they think is happening in Catalan region of Spain? Picking mushrooms?
No, its all about Zoran Zaev and Edi Rama making big promises to their respective people that joining the EU would bring wealth to their country. That is what its all about and now that the EU is short of cash and will not take on new members, all their promises of a better life are coming apart at the seams and their hold on power is looking tenuous.
(sj, 5 November 2019 10:25)
Joining the EU will do nothing for these countries except be given scraps and lots of new blue flags with yellow stars to put all over their government buildings, their population massively decrease and their politicians get even more richer
(Njegos down under, 5 November 2019 13:01)
Since Yugoslavia dissolved, there was always going to be a big question mark over the existence of the banana republic called Macedonia. Yugoslavia guaranteed the current Macedonia sovereignty and its constitution. Macedonia is hoping that the EU will take over from Yugoslavia, in fact opposite has happened. Bit by bit, every concession they made is creating their own demise. Like the UK will dissolve by 2025, Macedonia will cease to exist.
(Sl, 5 November 2019 12:11)
In general: Nationalism will not decrease by EU talks or membership, on the contrary it increases.
As for China and Russia, these so called fellows/academics that actually do not understand this region well at all need to get a better scapegoat. China and Russia are in the Balkans in the same capacity they have been there 5, 10, 15 years ago.
(Realist, 5 November 2019 12:38)
I never understood our idiot politicians and also our population also thinking that joining EU today will somehow as a miracle solve all our problems. Indeed its better to be equal in class called Balkan rather than a second hand citizien in a class called Europe.
We wasted 30 years of democracy with corruption, criminality, mass emigration etc to just open our eyes now and see we are again on the starting point. I wished someone comes in power with the idea to make things better for the albanian people, albanian cause, albanian problems first and only after see if its a need to join EU or whatever other organization. This is not easy because for decades now even the new generation has this idiot idea that getting rich faster by doing criminal things is better than beeing someone worthy for you society and your country. How can you blame them, for years the only thing they see on TV is peeps who start as poor politicians and end as top rank bilionaries in the region in just a decade
(Ordinary Albanian, 6 November 2019 20:11)
I certainly do not understand this statement.
Did they REALLY think that the EU, during forseeable future, would let these countries into the union??? With a huge amout of organized crime, poor people, nepotism, bribery, pollution and a risk for asylum seekers.
No not a chance in universe. A year ago, I talked with three french diplomats about this topic. One of them said 30 years and the other two said 30-40 years if everything goes smooth for the mentioned countries.
(Staff, 5 November 2019 18:44)
(Mikael, 6 November 2019 02:46)
I know exactly what Macedonia is and I know more about it’s history that you ever will. The current people are not Macedonians since they are Slavic and your language is Bulgarian, but pretending to be Macedonian of ancient times. Why is it I understand your language but not Greek? Alexander the Great was Greek but lived in that region which is called Macedonia and you people are not Macedonians the Greeks are.
It was Tito that pandered to minorities like yours into thinking your Macedonian.
It’s financially unsustainable just like all the others Croatia, BiH, Montenegro etc. Serbia is the only one that can stand on its feet and prosper as we can see today.
Zaev and Rama have been promising the world and once in the EU the bank vaults in heaven would open up and Utopia. Its their hold on power that has them shaking mate not getting N/Macedonia or Albania into the EU.
(sj, 7 November 2019 10:16)
I have nothing against North Macedonia. However I am very surprised at some of the decisions they have taken over the past 20/25 years.
Firstly I could not understand why they wanted to break away from Serbia. Looking at how it is, they don't really have any friends around them, apart from Serbia. To the east they have Bulgaria who have for a long time had their eyes on a chunk (or all) of Macedonia. To the south there is Greece. I need not say any more about Greek/Macedonian relations over the years. And then they have Albania....ye, those land thieves who are determined to rip a chunk of Macedonia for their greater Albania dream.
Macedonia is occupied by nato and are told what to do (sovereign nation my ass). And now we see how the EU is taking the pi*s out of them.
Can anyone tell me why the N Macedonians wanted to go their separate way...??? To me its a real mystery with no benefits.
(View from the uk, 6 November 2019 19:28)
What is there to educate on self about Macedonia? The Albanians have more support and respect around the world than the so called mythical state called Macedonia. The Albanians living within Macedonia are step by step gaining what they need thanks to the concessions made by so called Macedonians to appease the EU and NATO. Recognising Kosovo also meant border changes within Macedonia. Well done so called Macedonias, make your country great again like Tito times. Macedonia Macedonia, Macedonia!!!!!!!!!!
(Al, 7 November 2019 00:16)
sj,
You seem to know nothing about Macedonia, yet you talk as if you are an expert. Please educate yourself about Macedonia before you make a complete fool of yourself.
(Mikael, 6 November 2019 02:46)
@ Mikael - I'm not sure sj is far off. Macedonia signed on WAY to many dotted lines...giving up her sovereignty, Integrity & Character...all on promises that we see today hold no water.
Now what? Go back on the deal with the Albanians, which grabbed Macedonia by the boo-boo and now is laughing? Go back on the deal with Greece, who now is laughing? Go back on de-recognizing "kosovaaaa" for the Srbs, who now are laughing?
Zaev was chosen to sacrifice Macedonia on the alter...The "True" Macedonians know this! The "Macedonians" who appeased the alligator hoping to be eaten last....well, SHAME on you!
(Watcherovic, 6 November 2019 23:15)
sj,
You seem to know nothing about Macedonia, yet you talk as if you are an expert. Please educate yourself about Macedonia before you make a complete fool of yourself.
(Mikael, 6 November 2019 02:46)
Joining the EU will do nothing for these countries except be given scraps and lots of new blue flags with yellow stars to put all over their government buildings, their population massively decrease and their politicians get even more richer (Njegos down under, 5 November 2019 13:01)
Politicians get richer. And that's also why some Serbs left Serbia in favor of "down under" (Australia).
(Make Serbia Great, 5 November 2019 17:57)
sj,
You seem to know nothing about Macedonia, yet you talk as if you are an expert. Please educate yourself about Macedonia before you make a complete fool of yourself.
(Mikael, 6 November 2019 02:46)
Joining the EU will do nothing for these countries except be given scraps and lots of new blue flags with yellow stars to put all over their government buildings, their population massively decrease and their politicians get even more richer (Njegos down under, 5 November 2019 13:01)
Politicians get richer. And that's also why some Serbs left Serbia in favor of "down under" (Australia).
(Make Serbia Great, 5 November 2019 17:57)
Since Yugoslavia dissolved, there was always going to be a big question mark over the existence of the banana republic called Macedonia. Yugoslavia guaranteed the current Macedonia sovereignty and its constitution. Macedonia is hoping that the EU will take over from Yugoslavia, in fact opposite has happened. Bit by bit, every concession they made is creating their own demise. Like the UK will dissolve by 2025, Macedonia will cease to exist.
(Sl, 5 November 2019 12:11)
Miraculously joining the EU will somehow eliminate tension between different ethnic groups and no longer fuel nationalism??? What do they think is happening in Catalan region of Spain? Picking mushrooms?
No, its all about Zoran Zaev and Edi Rama making big promises to their respective people that joining the EU would bring wealth to their country. That is what its all about and now that the EU is short of cash and will not take on new members, all their promises of a better life are coming apart at the seams and their hold on power is looking tenuous.
(sj, 5 November 2019 10:25)
In general: Nationalism will not decrease by EU talks or membership, on the contrary it increases.
As for China and Russia, these so called fellows/academics that actually do not understand this region well at all need to get a better scapegoat. China and Russia are in the Balkans in the same capacity they have been there 5, 10, 15 years ago.
(Realist, 5 November 2019 12:38)
Joining the EU will do nothing for these countries except be given scraps and lots of new blue flags with yellow stars to put all over their government buildings, their population massively decrease and their politicians get even more richer
(Njegos down under, 5 November 2019 13:01)
I certainly do not understand this statement.
Did they REALLY think that the EU, during forseeable future, would let these countries into the union??? With a huge amout of organized crime, poor people, nepotism, bribery, pollution and a risk for asylum seekers.
No not a chance in universe. A year ago, I talked with three french diplomats about this topic. One of them said 30 years and the other two said 30-40 years if everything goes smooth for the mentioned countries.
(Staff, 5 November 2019 18:44)
What is there to educate on self about Macedonia? The Albanians have more support and respect around the world than the so called mythical state called Macedonia. The Albanians living within Macedonia are step by step gaining what they need thanks to the concessions made by so called Macedonians to appease the EU and NATO. Recognising Kosovo also meant border changes within Macedonia. Well done so called Macedonias, make your country great again like Tito times. Macedonia Macedonia, Macedonia!!!!!!!!!!
(Al, 7 November 2019 00:16)
(Mikael, 6 November 2019 02:46)
I know exactly what Macedonia is and I know more about it’s history that you ever will. The current people are not Macedonians since they are Slavic and your language is Bulgarian, but pretending to be Macedonian of ancient times. Why is it I understand your language but not Greek? Alexander the Great was Greek but lived in that region which is called Macedonia and you people are not Macedonians the Greeks are.
It was Tito that pandered to minorities like yours into thinking your Macedonian.
It’s financially unsustainable just like all the others Croatia, BiH, Montenegro etc. Serbia is the only one that can stand on its feet and prosper as we can see today.
Zaev and Rama have been promising the world and once in the EU the bank vaults in heaven would open up and Utopia. Its their hold on power that has them shaking mate not getting N/Macedonia or Albania into the EU.
(sj, 7 November 2019 10:16)
I have nothing against North Macedonia. However I am very surprised at some of the decisions they have taken over the past 20/25 years.
Firstly I could not understand why they wanted to break away from Serbia. Looking at how it is, they don't really have any friends around them, apart from Serbia. To the east they have Bulgaria who have for a long time had their eyes on a chunk (or all) of Macedonia. To the south there is Greece. I need not say any more about Greek/Macedonian relations over the years. And then they have Albania....ye, those land thieves who are determined to rip a chunk of Macedonia for their greater Albania dream.
Macedonia is occupied by nato and are told what to do (sovereign nation my ass). And now we see how the EU is taking the pi*s out of them.
Can anyone tell me why the N Macedonians wanted to go their separate way...??? To me its a real mystery with no benefits.
(View from the uk, 6 November 2019 19:28)
I never understood our idiot politicians and also our population also thinking that joining EU today will somehow as a miracle solve all our problems. Indeed its better to be equal in class called Balkan rather than a second hand citizien in a class called Europe.
We wasted 30 years of democracy with corruption, criminality, mass emigration etc to just open our eyes now and see we are again on the starting point. I wished someone comes in power with the idea to make things better for the albanian people, albanian cause, albanian problems first and only after see if its a need to join EU or whatever other organization. This is not easy because for decades now even the new generation has this idiot idea that getting rich faster by doing criminal things is better than beeing someone worthy for you society and your country. How can you blame them, for years the only thing they see on TV is peeps who start as poor politicians and end as top rank bilionaries in the region in just a decade
(Ordinary Albanian, 6 November 2019 20:11)
sj,
You seem to know nothing about Macedonia, yet you talk as if you are an expert. Please educate yourself about Macedonia before you make a complete fool of yourself.
(Mikael, 6 November 2019 02:46)
@ Mikael - I'm not sure sj is far off. Macedonia signed on WAY to many dotted lines...giving up her sovereignty, Integrity & Character...all on promises that we see today hold no water.
Now what? Go back on the deal with the Albanians, which grabbed Macedonia by the boo-boo and now is laughing? Go back on the deal with Greece, who now is laughing? Go back on de-recognizing "kosovaaaa" for the Srbs, who now are laughing?
Zaev was chosen to sacrifice Macedonia on the alter...The "True" Macedonians know this! The "Macedonians" who appeased the alligator hoping to be eaten last....well, SHAME on you!
(Watcherovic, 6 November 2019 23:15)