Greta Thunberg's speech in UN confirms that children suffer from the death cult of eco-alarmism, Brendan O'Neill, editor of British internet-portal Spiked says
"Forget saving the planet – we need to save Greta!"
Greta Thunberg's speech in UN confirms that children suffer from the death cult of eco-alarmism, Brendan O'Neill, editor of British internet-portal Spiked says
Source: B92
Close the entire text of the article here
Tanjug/AP Photo/Mary Altaffer
In his op-ed piece entitled "Save Greta", he pointed out that any adult that cheered Greta Thunberg's speech in the United Nations should be ashamed of themselves.
"Her emotional rant was a deeply disturbing spectacle. It revealed a young woman, a girl, in essence, who is in the grip of terror, of a morbid, debilitating belief that life as we know it is coming to an end. You could not have asked for firmer proof that the green ideology is seriously screwing up the next generation by pumping them with fear and panic and a deranged belief that the end of the world is nigh. It isn’t the planet that needs saving – it’s Greta. She needs to be saved from the death cult of eco-alarmism", O'Neill underlines in his article.
Editor of British internet-portal stressed that "it was a truly sad sight", adding that Greta's tears were understandable, given that she is convinced that life on Earth is being "suffocated and murdered by greedy, marauding mankind".
"With each nightmarish word, with each unhinged dystopian prediction of doom, her voice wobbled and her emotions span out of control. It was a public meltdown. And of course the politicians applauded it – perversely, they love nothing more than being told how awful they are", O'Neill wrote.
Author asks himself "who did this to Greta?"
"Who turned a bright and curious 16-year-old schoolgirl into a prophet of horror, into a young woman who admits to feeling terror and who believes the Earth is on fire? Adults did. The green-infused educational, political and cultural elites did. The people who have been feeding kids a narrative of eco-fear for years did this. Their secular Armageddonism, their wilful exaggeration of every problem mankind faces, their marshalling of the politics of fear to try to force people to change their allegedly wicked, eco-harmful behaviour – all of this has convinced many young people that the future is dark, mankind is doomed, and there is no point even going to school, far less planning one’s life, because we will all be dead soon. They did this to Greta, and to others, and it is unforgivable", O'Neill concludes.
O'Neill also commented on the words of the UN general-secretary Antonio Guterres. Opening the UN Climate Action Summit yesterday, at which Greta made her frazzled, tragic speech, he said: ‘Nature is angry.’
"What is this superstition? It is positively pre-modern. This anthropomorphising of nature is central to the eco-alarmist outlook. It presents everything from forest fires to floods as punishment for humankind’s sins, as nature’s payback to the pox that is humanity and our ‘fairytales of eternal economic growth’, as Greta describes it. In Biblical times, freak weather and plagues of locusts were viewed as God’s punishment of human beings’ sinful behaviour; now we hear talk of ‘weather of mass destruction’ and ‘angry’ natural events that are apparently Gaia’s punishment of us for committing the sin of economic growth. The words change, but the backwardness and hysteria are eerily similar", the author warns, adding that Greta Thunberg deserves respect in many ways.
"She is driven and articulate. But it is patently clear now that she is being exploited. She is being pushed to the forefront of 'the most fearful' and superstitious movement of our times. She has been turned into the chief spokesperson for doom, the mouthpiece of eco-misanthropy, a soothsayer of the horrors humankind will allegedly bring upon itself. The aim seems to be to make environmentalism an unquestionable, untouchable ideology. Witness how anyone who raises even a peep of criticism of eco-nonsense will now be asked: ‘How dare you criticise Greta and the other brave climate-striking children?’ These kids are being used as moral shields by adults to protect the increasingly bizarre politics of environmentalism from interrogation and criticism. It is dizzying in its cynicism", he pointed out, adding that this amount of cynicism is destructive of public debate, destructive of critical discussion, and destructive of the kids "who are being dragged into this terrifying, miserabilist worldview to play the role of a stage army to adult society’s own loss of faith in mankind and in economic growth".
"Enough. Set Greta free. Stop instructing her in the cult of fear and let her go back to school and to a normal youthful life".
O'Neill raises the following question: "if you really must have a child speaking at the UN, how about a teenager from Africa or India who believes economic growth is not a fairytale but absolutely essential to their liberation from poverty?"
"We’ve all heard more than enough from middle-class Westerners who think economic growth is oh-so-horrible. Let’s hear from someone in the teeming billions around the world who profoundly disagree with this downbeat, anti-human, Western-centric crap", said O'Neill, making his final point in the article.
The problem with climate change is that there are too many interest groups out there stirring up hysteria. This teenager is being used and, as Peggy stated, this is a form of child abuse. The problem with climate change is a lack of debate using real science on the subject.
For example, while you have people yelling the sky is falling in Sydney, Australia, Fort Denison, was built in the 1800s to protect the harbour. For the last 150 years it has measured not only tide, but sea water levels. Today, the sea water level is lower than in 1914, but how is that possible when ocean levels are supposed to be increasing?
Then the claim that climate change is affecting the Great Barrier Reef, off the Australian State of Queensland. A James Cook University academic, who has studied the reef for over 30 years, and a renowned world expert on the subject, said the reef was fine and it was not being destroyed by agricultural runoff or warming of the waters. Indonesia has the same coral species and part of that country is on the equator thus 2% warmer than the Great Barrier Reef, but the coral is thriving there.
The academic was sacked from his professorial position because in the last decade and a half about $10 trillion has been spent world-wide on climate change research and no university wants to kill the goose that lays the golden egg.
Its fact that wind and solar cannot generate enough electricity to meet our needs.
(sj, 30 September 2019 09:53)
Her parents should be charged with child abuse. To allow people like Soros to get their hands on their child with a mental illness is unforgivable. These evil globalists think they can say whatever they want as long as they are hiding behind a child is not going to work. We are not going to challenge her, because she doesn't have a clue about what she is doing but we can and should go after her Antifa parents and the rest of the adults who have put this child in harms way. Sadly, she might even attempt self harm one day if this keeps going. She is clearly showing sings on not coping. If that happens, I know they will attempt to blame the people who disagree with her and her handlers but it won't fly.
Time to save Greta, firstly from her evil parents.
(Peggy, 27 September 2019 11:23)
This article and the comments so far do not acknowledge that there is a problem with the climate and that things ARE being done about it. (Too slowly maybe, but there is action.)
There is no reason not to find alternatives to excessive carbon burning. There is no reason not to protect wild life and preserve an environment which nature can continue as it has for millions of years before.
It is not enough to label children as being disturbed (even if they are) and there is every reason to address their concerns.
I do agree that she is too extreme in her thinking. I do however acknowledge that she is rightly attacking a terrible amount of complacency.
(Bob, 27 September 2019 07:22)
Greta, you are doing a great job! World needs people like you and in 10 years from now these same dummies that are denying scientific evidence on global warming will be singing a different tune, but by then it might be too late.
(Global, 26 September 2019 17:12)
This is disgusting, and why B92 chooses to publish this reactionary piece in vivid detail is beyond me. Imagine grown men getting so worked up over a 16 year old girl who is doing nothing more than relaying information previously published by reputable scientists. Who'd have thought she'd trigger so many angry paranoid 8chan incels obsessed with trying to sound smart by making fun of her looks or mannerisms - and those are the tame ones. Pathetic.
(Balkan Anthropologist, 26 September 2019 16:23)
Solid points here. I only disagree with his reading of the Old Testament. God surely did punish the disobedient, and he certainly does today. People just can't read the signs of the times.
(Make Serbia Great, 26 September 2019 15:31)
Maybe Greta needs to look at her own selfish generation before attacking the adults! It's the millennials who are the biggest consumers of manufactured good! The first generation to require air-conditioning in schools, and your classrooms are all computerised. You want a TV in every room of the house and you're constantly on mobile phones and electronic devices and always update them to stay trendy! You don't walk or ride bikes to school, but arrive in convoys of vans and suvs that pollute the air and choke traffic. If the kids want to save the planet, why don't they start with themselves! Switch off the mobile phone, TV, aircon and read a book, ride a bike or walk to school. But that will never happen because you are all selfish, virtue signalling brats!
(So sad, too bad, 26 September 2019 13:17)
Maybe Greta needs to look at her own selfish generation before attacking the adults! It's the millennials who are the biggest consumers of manufactured good! The first generation to require air-conditioning in schools, and your classrooms are all computerised. You want a TV in every room of the house and you're constantly on mobile phones and electronic devices and always update them to stay trendy! You don't walk or ride bikes to school, but arrive in convoys of vans and suvs that pollute the air and choke traffic. If the kids want to save the planet, why don't they start with themselves! Switch off the mobile phone, TV, aircon and read a book, ride a bike or walk to school. But that will never happen because you are all selfish, virtue signalling brats!
(So sad, too bad, 26 September 2019 13:17)
Her parents should be charged with child abuse. To allow people like Soros to get their hands on their child with a mental illness is unforgivable. These evil globalists think they can say whatever they want as long as they are hiding behind a child is not going to work. We are not going to challenge her, because she doesn't have a clue about what she is doing but we can and should go after her Antifa parents and the rest of the adults who have put this child in harms way. Sadly, she might even attempt self harm one day if this keeps going. She is clearly showing sings on not coping. If that happens, I know they will attempt to blame the people who disagree with her and her handlers but it won't fly.
Time to save Greta, firstly from her evil parents.
(Peggy, 27 September 2019 11:23)
Solid points here. I only disagree with his reading of the Old Testament. God surely did punish the disobedient, and he certainly does today. People just can't read the signs of the times.
(Make Serbia Great, 26 September 2019 15:31)
Greta, you are doing a great job! World needs people like you and in 10 years from now these same dummies that are denying scientific evidence on global warming will be singing a different tune, but by then it might be too late.
(Global, 26 September 2019 17:12)
The problem with climate change is that there are too many interest groups out there stirring up hysteria. This teenager is being used and, as Peggy stated, this is a form of child abuse. The problem with climate change is a lack of debate using real science on the subject.
For example, while you have people yelling the sky is falling in Sydney, Australia, Fort Denison, was built in the 1800s to protect the harbour. For the last 150 years it has measured not only tide, but sea water levels. Today, the sea water level is lower than in 1914, but how is that possible when ocean levels are supposed to be increasing?
Then the claim that climate change is affecting the Great Barrier Reef, off the Australian State of Queensland. A James Cook University academic, who has studied the reef for over 30 years, and a renowned world expert on the subject, said the reef was fine and it was not being destroyed by agricultural runoff or warming of the waters. Indonesia has the same coral species and part of that country is on the equator thus 2% warmer than the Great Barrier Reef, but the coral is thriving there.
The academic was sacked from his professorial position because in the last decade and a half about $10 trillion has been spent world-wide on climate change research and no university wants to kill the goose that lays the golden egg.
Its fact that wind and solar cannot generate enough electricity to meet our needs.
(sj, 30 September 2019 09:53)
This is disgusting, and why B92 chooses to publish this reactionary piece in vivid detail is beyond me. Imagine grown men getting so worked up over a 16 year old girl who is doing nothing more than relaying information previously published by reputable scientists. Who'd have thought she'd trigger so many angry paranoid 8chan incels obsessed with trying to sound smart by making fun of her looks or mannerisms - and those are the tame ones. Pathetic.
(Balkan Anthropologist, 26 September 2019 16:23)
This article and the comments so far do not acknowledge that there is a problem with the climate and that things ARE being done about it. (Too slowly maybe, but there is action.)
There is no reason not to find alternatives to excessive carbon burning. There is no reason not to protect wild life and preserve an environment which nature can continue as it has for millions of years before.
It is not enough to label children as being disturbed (even if they are) and there is every reason to address their concerns.
I do agree that she is too extreme in her thinking. I do however acknowledge that she is rightly attacking a terrible amount of complacency.
(Bob, 27 September 2019 07:22)
Greta, you are doing a great job! World needs people like you and in 10 years from now these same dummies that are denying scientific evidence on global warming will be singing a different tune, but by then it might be too late.
(Global, 26 September 2019 17:12)
Maybe Greta needs to look at her own selfish generation before attacking the adults! It's the millennials who are the biggest consumers of manufactured good! The first generation to require air-conditioning in schools, and your classrooms are all computerised. You want a TV in every room of the house and you're constantly on mobile phones and electronic devices and always update them to stay trendy! You don't walk or ride bikes to school, but arrive in convoys of vans and suvs that pollute the air and choke traffic. If the kids want to save the planet, why don't they start with themselves! Switch off the mobile phone, TV, aircon and read a book, ride a bike or walk to school. But that will never happen because you are all selfish, virtue signalling brats!
(So sad, too bad, 26 September 2019 13:17)
This is disgusting, and why B92 chooses to publish this reactionary piece in vivid detail is beyond me. Imagine grown men getting so worked up over a 16 year old girl who is doing nothing more than relaying information previously published by reputable scientists. Who'd have thought she'd trigger so many angry paranoid 8chan incels obsessed with trying to sound smart by making fun of her looks or mannerisms - and those are the tame ones. Pathetic.
(Balkan Anthropologist, 26 September 2019 16:23)
Solid points here. I only disagree with his reading of the Old Testament. God surely did punish the disobedient, and he certainly does today. People just can't read the signs of the times.
(Make Serbia Great, 26 September 2019 15:31)
Her parents should be charged with child abuse. To allow people like Soros to get their hands on their child with a mental illness is unforgivable. These evil globalists think they can say whatever they want as long as they are hiding behind a child is not going to work. We are not going to challenge her, because she doesn't have a clue about what she is doing but we can and should go after her Antifa parents and the rest of the adults who have put this child in harms way. Sadly, she might even attempt self harm one day if this keeps going. She is clearly showing sings on not coping. If that happens, I know they will attempt to blame the people who disagree with her and her handlers but it won't fly.
Time to save Greta, firstly from her evil parents.
(Peggy, 27 September 2019 11:23)
This article and the comments so far do not acknowledge that there is a problem with the climate and that things ARE being done about it. (Too slowly maybe, but there is action.)
There is no reason not to find alternatives to excessive carbon burning. There is no reason not to protect wild life and preserve an environment which nature can continue as it has for millions of years before.
It is not enough to label children as being disturbed (even if they are) and there is every reason to address their concerns.
I do agree that she is too extreme in her thinking. I do however acknowledge that she is rightly attacking a terrible amount of complacency.
(Bob, 27 September 2019 07:22)
The problem with climate change is that there are too many interest groups out there stirring up hysteria. This teenager is being used and, as Peggy stated, this is a form of child abuse. The problem with climate change is a lack of debate using real science on the subject.
For example, while you have people yelling the sky is falling in Sydney, Australia, Fort Denison, was built in the 1800s to protect the harbour. For the last 150 years it has measured not only tide, but sea water levels. Today, the sea water level is lower than in 1914, but how is that possible when ocean levels are supposed to be increasing?
Then the claim that climate change is affecting the Great Barrier Reef, off the Australian State of Queensland. A James Cook University academic, who has studied the reef for over 30 years, and a renowned world expert on the subject, said the reef was fine and it was not being destroyed by agricultural runoff or warming of the waters. Indonesia has the same coral species and part of that country is on the equator thus 2% warmer than the Great Barrier Reef, but the coral is thriving there.
The academic was sacked from his professorial position because in the last decade and a half about $10 trillion has been spent world-wide on climate change research and no university wants to kill the goose that lays the golden egg.
Its fact that wind and solar cannot generate enough electricity to meet our needs.
(sj, 30 September 2019 09:53)